Frankentrim: “You Get What You Pay For” or “Beware the Low Bid”

I like to keep things very positive on my blog, and so I prefer not to critique other carpenter’s work because we all work at different experience levels. But if you are going to hire someone to install your moldings, you should expect at least a minimum level of craftsmanship. After all, finish carpentry is all about attention to detail — that’s what you’re paying for.

The following examples of “professional” molding installations should serve as a warning to you that not all who call themselves finish carpenters share the same definition of finish.

Above The contractor on this project said his crew could trim the French double doors they installed. Looking at the quality of their finish skills, I’m surprised they ever managed to get the door installed. Or get paid.

Below This is the same door trim as in the above picture. I’d like to know at what point in your development as a “professional” craftsman you can look at this baseboard and say, “Boss, I’m finished blending the baseboard.” I couldn’t let my client live with this mess, so I came up with DOOR TRIM-133.

All you need now is a case of caulk and a blind eye.
Below I took the four pictures below in a $500,000.00 townhouse show model. All of these moldings had been “professionally” installed and painted only a few months before I took these photos.

To keep the two pieces of this horizontal wall treatment thing from separating like this, all the carpenter would have had to do is join them with a scarf joint. Also, both sides of the joint should have been glued with a strong construction adhesive.

A scarf joint may have kept this molding from separating.
Below Open end cuts that expose the wood grain is bad form, since a simple return would make a nicer surface. If an end cut is necessary, the least the carpenter can do is sand the end grain smooth.

And don’t even get me started on that green over-paint on the molding.

No open end cuts allowed.
Below It’s the paint job on this wall that I want to highlight here.

This crown molding was masked off and then the walls painted. When the tape was pulled up the wall paint went with it. Avoid this kind of mess by reading our How to Paint Moldings page.

Below This is why I harp on gluing every single molding contact surface.

Below Don’t allow your finish carpenter to leave open end cuts like this. The proper method is a return to the wall.

Below This low ceiling in front of a half bath made it necessary for the contractor who initially remodeled this place to do a dissolve at the top of the door — nothing wrong with that.

But he could have at least made an effort to make it dissolve into the ceiling. Read more about the proper way to dissolve moldings here.

There just is no excuse for this kind of workmanship no matter what the price point. Nor is there an excuse for the typo I put in the picture. Gotta’ fix that.
The best way to avoid a confrontation with your finish carpenter over poor craftsmanship is to make sure you communicate your expectations in advance.


One Response

    I just want to mention I am just new to weblog and truly loved this web blog. More than likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You definitely come with impressive articles and reviews. Bless you for sharing with us your web-site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *